WAY 114 / CHANGE
Permanent linkQuestion the order
See how changing the order changes the story.
When
You have chosen an order for images or scenes without considering what it suggests.
The Way
John Berger told viewers they receive 'images and meanings which are arranged'. Be sceptical of the arrangement, he said. Question the order of your own work.
Try
Take two or three images, scenes or paragraphs and put them in two different orders. Write one line on the story each order tells, and one on what neither shows.
Notice
Which order would you keep, and what would it lead someone to believe?
Example
A filmmaker puts a crowd shot before a closed factory gate, then reverses them. One order suggests arrival; the other, a response to closure. Neither proves why the crowd gathered.
Reference quote and source
Remember that I am controlling, and using for my own purposes, the means of reproduction needed for these programmes. The images may be like words, but there’s no dialogue yet — you cannot reply to me. For that to become possible in the modern media of communication, access to television must be extended beyond its present narrow limits. Meanwhile, with this programme, as with all programmes, you receive images and meanings which are arranged. I hope you will consider what I arrange. But be skeptical of it.
Condensed from the linked clip. Check the clip before quoting. Artificial Milieu wrote the exercise and example; the speaker did not write or endorse them.
{
"id": "question-the-order",
"number": "114",
"edition": "Change",
"title": "Question the order",
"standfirst": "See how changing the order changes the story.",
"when": "You have chosen an order for images or scenes without considering what it suggests.",
"way": "John Berger told viewers they receive 'images and meanings which are arranged'. Be sceptical of the arrangement, he said. Question the order of your own work.",
"tryThis": "Take two or three images, scenes or paragraphs and put them in two different orders. Write one line on the story each order tells, and one on what neither shows.",
"notice": "Which order would you keep, and what would it lead someone to believe?",
"example": "A filmmaker puts a crowd shot before a closed factory gate, then reverses them. One order suggests arrival; the other, a response to closure. Neither proves why the crowd gathered.",
"person": "John Berger",
"source": "Artificial Milieu archive",
"quote": "Remember that I am controlling, and using for my own purposes, the means of reproduction needed for these programmes. The images may be like words, but there’s no dialogue yet — you cannot reply to me. For that to become possible in the modern media of communication, access to television must be extended beyond its present narrow limits. \n\nMeanwhile, with this programme, as with all programmes, you receive images and meanings which are arranged. I hope you will consider what I arrange. But be skeptical of it.",
"sourceUrl": "https://youtu.be/8wxRxSfhw6I",
"contexts": [
"perspective",
"change"
],
"free": true,
"related": [
"remove-competing-elements",
"make-the-detail-earn-its-place"
],
"sourceArchive": "The Contemporary Blueprint / Artificial Milieu",
"referenceKind": "condensed reference passage",
"referenceExcerpt": "Remember that I am controlling, and using for my own purposes, the means of reproduction needed for these programmes. The images may be like words, but there’s no dialogue yet — you cannot reply to me. For that to become possible in the modern media of communication, access to television must be extended beyond its present narrow limits. \n\nMeanwhile, with this programme, as with all programmes, you receive images and meanings which are arranged. I hope you will consider what I arrange. But be skeptical of it."
}