All Ways

WAY 112 / CHANGE

Permanent link

Make the detail earn its place

Keep what contributes to the work.

When

A passage or image contains details that fill space without effect.

The Way

Susan Sontag said every detail has to be powerful and thrilling. Make each one earn its place.

Try

Find one detail that only fills space. Replace it with a precise one that reveals something, or cut it. Then look at the whole again.

Notice

What does the whole gain or lose after the change?

Example

A writer replaces 'an old room' with a description of a worn chair arm, giving the reader a specific sign of how the room has been used.

Reference quote and source
I would say every detail has to be powerful, every detail has to be thrilling, and then after the fact, because a story should have some quality of inevitability or necessity, and perhaps it’s that, that gives it some essential quality.

Condensed from the linked clip. Check the clip before quoting. Artificial Milieu wrote the exercise and example; the speaker did not write or endorse them.

{
  "id": "make-the-detail-earn-its-place",
  "number": "112",
  "edition": "Change",
  "title": "Make the detail earn its place",
  "standfirst": "Keep what contributes to the work.",
  "when": "A passage or image contains details that fill space without effect.",
  "way": "Susan Sontag said every detail has to be powerful and thrilling. Make each one earn its place.",
  "tryThis": "Find one detail that only fills space. Replace it with a precise one that reveals something, or cut it. Then look at the whole again.",
  "notice": "What does the whole gain or lose after the change?",
  "example": "A writer replaces 'an old room' with a description of a worn chair arm, giving the reader a specific sign of how the room has been used.",
  "person": "Susan Sontag",
  "source": "Artificial Milieu archive",
  "quote": "I would say every detail has to be powerful, every detail has to be thrilling, and then after the fact, because a story should have some quality of inevitability or necessity, and perhaps it’s that, that gives it some essential quality.",
  "sourceUrl": "https://youtu.be/MoHCR8nshe8",
  "contexts": [
    "decide",
    "change"
  ],
  "free": true,
  "related": [
    "remove-competing-elements",
    "question-the-order"
  ],
  "sourceArchive": "The Contemporary Blueprint / Artificial Milieu",
  "referenceKind": "condensed reference passage",
  "referenceExcerpt": "I would say every detail has to be powerful, every detail has to be thrilling, and then after the fact, because a story should have some quality of inevitability or necessity, and perhaps it’s that, that gives it some essential quality."
}

Related Way: Remove competing elements

Download Twelve Ways.

Get twelve complete Ways, printable cards and optional files for your own AI chat. Enter your email, then confirm your address to receive the collection.

Loading the signup form. Open signup directly in Kit (opens in a new tab).

Confirm by email. You'll also join Artificial Milieu, a newsletter about art, media and machines. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy.