All Ways

WAY 011 / 01 IDEAS

Permanent link

Try the bad idea

An intentionally wrong direction can reveal what sensible thinking keeps hidden.

When

Everything you produce feels predictable, correct and strangely lifeless.

The Way

A deliberately bad, strange or dangerous idea can move the work outside the route your judgment already knows how to approve. The aim is not to make something bad. It is to gather information from somewhere less familiar.

Try

Make the version you would normally reject first. Exaggerate what feels wrong about it. Then identify one quality worth carrying back into the work.

Notice

What appeared when being sensible was no longer the objective?

Reference quote and source
“We never know until we try things what works, and what doesn’t. I often think of a bad idea and on purpose, try that bad idea, just to see where it leads. Sometimes it turns out not to be bad, sometimes it’s worse than I thought, but, the spark of seeing this bad idea through, you start recognising where it can go. It’s a bad idea, but if this part of it got amplified, and this part went away, maybe it’s be more interesting, and that’s the next iteration. It’s a series of iterations and looking for clues. Look for bad ideas, strange ideas, dangerous ideas, and see what happens.”
Related: give it a temporary name
{
  "id": "try-the-bad-idea",
  "number": "011",
  "edition": "Ideas",
  "title": "Try the bad idea",
  "standfirst": "An intentionally wrong direction can reveal what sensible thinking keeps hidden.",
  "when": "Everything you produce feels predictable, correct and strangely lifeless.",
  "way": "A deliberately bad, strange or dangerous idea can move the work outside the route your judgment already knows how to approve. The aim is not to make something bad. It is to gather information from somewhere less familiar.",
  "tryThis": "Make the version you would normally reject first. Exaggerate what feels wrong about it. Then identify one quality worth carrying back into the work.",
  "notice": "What appeared when being sensible was no longer the objective?",
  "person": "Rick Rubin",
  "source": "The Contemporary Blueprint archive",
  "quote": "We never know until we try things what works, and what doesn’t. I often think of a bad idea and on purpose, try that bad idea, just to see where it leads. Sometimes it turns out not to be bad, sometimes it’s worse than I thought, but, the spark of seeing this bad idea through, you start recognising where it can go.\n\nIt’s a bad idea, but if this part of it got amplified, and this part went away, maybe it’s be more interesting, and that’s the next iteration. It’s a series of iterations and looking for clues. Look for bad ideas, strange ideas, dangerous ideas, and see what happens.",
  "sourceUrl": "https://youtu.be/60pHJXUjaJY",
  "contexts": [
    "idea",
    "stuck",
    "perspective"
  ],
  "free": true,
  "related": [
    "give-it-a-temporary-name",
    "make-the-decision-visible",
    "make-the-first-mark"
  ],
  "sourceArchive": "The Contemporary Blueprint",
  "referenceKind": "quotation",
  "referenceExcerpt": "We never know until we try things what works, and what doesn’t. I often think of a bad idea and on purpose, try that bad idea, just to see where it leads. Sometimes it turns out not to be bad, sometimes it’s worse than I thought, but, the spark of seeing this bad idea through, you start recognising where it can go."
}

Hear when the editions are ready.

Join Artificial Milieu, Steve Sharp's newsletter about creativity and technology, and receive release notices for the three editions and Complete. Unsubscribe at any time.